Choosing the right forex broker is crucial for any trader, whether you’re just starting out or have been trading for years. Two of the most important factors to consider are spread and execution. These metrics can significantly impact your trading costs and, ultimately, your profitability. Understanding what they mean and how they affect your trades is essential before making a decision about where to open your trading account.
What is Spread?
Spread is the difference between the ‘bid’ price (the price a broker is willing to buy a currency pair from you) and the ‘ask’ price (the price a broker is willing to sell a currency pair to you). In simpler terms, it’s the transaction cost you pay directly to your broker for each trade. When you see a quote for EUR/USD, for example, you might see something like 1.0850/1.0852. The two prices aren’t identical, and this minuscule difference of 0.0002 is the spread. It’s what the broker earns on every trade as compensation for providing the service.
Types of Spreads
There are generally two primary types of spreads to be aware of:
- Fixed Spread: With a fixed spread, the difference between the bid and ask price remains constant regardless of market conditions. This can provide predictable costs, but fixed spreads usually tend to be higher than variable spreads. They are often offered by brokers who are dealing desk brokers and are taking the other side of your trade. This means your broker might make more profit from your losses and vice versa.
- Variable Spread: Also known as floating spread, this type of spread fluctuates based on market supply and demand, volatility and overall liquidity. During periods of high market activity or news events, the variable spread is likely to widen, becoming more expensive but during calmer markets the spread can be narrower. Variable spreads are more often provided by brokers who use a Straight Through Processing (STP) or ECN model where trades are directly routed through to a liquidity provider.
Understanding Execution
Execution refers to how efficiently and quickly your trades are processed by your broker. It involves the mechanism through which your broker fills an order at the desired or expected price. A good broker will provide fast, accurate execution that avoids slippage (getting a price worse than expected) and requotes (when a broker rejects your order at the requested price and offers it to you at a new, usually less favourable, price). There are different types of execution models that brokers may use. These often have direct links their cost structures and methods of trading the financial markets:
Execution Models
- Market Makers / Dealing Desk: Brokers that operate on a market-maker model act as principals to trades. Usually they offer fixed spreads and may take the other side of your trades. If you are buying, the market making broker is selling to you the currency pair and vice versa. There can be times the market maker may delay or even reject your execution which can often be termed as ‘slippage’, meaning your order executes but at a a less favorable price to the one you were originally expecting.
- Straight Through Processing (STP): With STP, broker’s pass trade orders directly to their liquidity providers, often tier-one and tier-two banks. There’s no dealing desk interfering with your order and as such trades are executed quickly and efficiently. STP brokers can offer narrower, although variable spreads.
- Electronic Communications Network (ECN): ECN brokers aim to connect all market participants directly, allowing them to trade with one another. ECN brokers are able to offer very tight spreads usually but due to their transparent market, execution speeds can vary based on volume and market liquidity.
Key Aspects of Good Execution
When evaluating a brokers execution, pay attention to:
- Speed: Fast execution ensures that orders are filled quickly and at the intended prices, reducing the likelihood of slippage.
- Slippage: Slippage is the difference between the expected price for your trade and its actual execution price. Low slippage is essential for accurate trading.
- Requotes: A good broker will provide minimal or no requotes, ensuring your order is filled at the intended price.
- Fill Rate: A high fill rate ensures that most of the orders are processed successfully, especially during volatile periods when liquidity can be scarce.
How Spread and Execution Affect Your Trading
Both spread and execution have a significant impact on your overall trading performance.
- Trading Costs: The spread directly affects your costs. A wider spread means that you pay more to enter and exit a position, eating into your trading profit. Small spreads can make a big difference over many trades.
- Profitability: Combined with poor execution, wider spreads can diminish your profitability or even cause consistent losses. In fast moving markets it’s imperative your trades execute with minimal delays.
- Scalping and Day Trading: These trading styles which involve taking many positions in a single day are particularly vulnerable to the impact of wide spreads and poor execution. Even a small increase in the spread can cut drastically into the profits that a day trader can take.
Choosing a Broker: Focusing on Spreads and Execution
When selecting a forex broker, evaluate the following based on spread and execution:
- Transparency: Understand how a broker handles your orders . Do they use an STP or ECN model, or are they a dealing desk broker? This will affect execution and slippage potential
- Competitive Spreads: Compare spreads offered for the currency pairs you intend to trade. Understand that variable spreads can often look attractive on the screen but can fluctuate based on market conditions. Look for average spreads rather than just an absolute minimum.
- Execution Speed: Look for brokers that provide information on their execution speeds. Consider this in relation to their liquidity sources and order routing.
- Slippage and Requotes: Check reviews and brokers terms and conditions to better understand how they handle slippage and requotes. Always trade with a demo account to get and idea of their executions before committing to a live trading environment.
- Account Types: Often brokers will offer different account types, some aimed at day traders that provide tighter spreads for a commission based structure while others may widen the spread slightly to have a zero commission. Choose the one that best aligns with your trading style.
Other Important Factors to Consider
While spread and execution are paramount, consider other important factors when making a decision about a broker:
- Regulation: Trading with a regulated broker is paramount for safety and transparency. Choose brokers that are licensed by reputable financial authorities.
- Trading Platform: Select a platform that meets your needs. Options will vary in terms of charting tools, automation and ease of use.
- Customer Support: Responsive and helpful customer service is essential, especially when something technical goes wrong.
- Fees & Charges: Look at other fees such as deposit and withdrawal charges, overnight holding costs (also known as swaps), potential administration charges and any platform access fees.
Conclusion
Spread and execution are crucial metrics in forex trading. Understanding the impact these two factors have on your overall costs and potential profitability is essential. Select a broker that provides competitive spreads combined with strong, reliable execution. Consider all other factors too, ensuring you choose a broker who is regulated, dependable and is in line with your trading needs and style. These steps will go a long way to helping you achieve more sustainable results in the global currency markets.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is considered a good spread?
A: A good spread is relative to the instruments being traded and also market conditions. For major currency pairs, you’ll generally look for spreads of less than one pip on average. Always compare the average spread over multiple periods and when markets are busy, not just the absolute best value available.
Q: Are fixed spreads always better than variable spreads?
A: Not necessarily. Fixed spreads offer predictability but are often higher. Variable spreads may be lower but can widen during volatile periods. It all depends on the type of trader you are and your trading style.
Q: How can I test a broker’s execution without opening a live account?
A: Most brokers offer demo accounts that allow you to experience their trading environment, including execution speed and slippage, without risking real capital.
Q: What is slippage, and why is it important?
A: Slippage is when your trade executes at a different price than what you requested. Especially during times of high volatility and rapid price movement, slippage is common. Reduced slippage leads to more accurate trades.
Q: How can I find information about a broker’s regulation?
A: A regulated broker will generally publish their regulatory information clearly on their company website, usually at the bottom of most pages. Check with the specific regulatory body to confirm they are correctly registered.
References
- Investopedia: Forex Broker
- Babypips: Understanding Forex Execution
- DailyFX: Choosing a Forex Broker
Are you ready to trade? Explore our recommended brokers here and start trading with us!